TestGorilla LogoTestGorilla Logo
Pricing
homeLibraryBlog

Our latest report reveals a paradox at the heart of hiring

TestGorilla staff

We surveyed 1,000 US HR and recruiting leaders. The results show teams struggle to verify skills, assess culture fit, and find qualified candidates – with only 37% prepared for an AI-driven future.

TestGorilla's latest report, Unlocking Sourcing Success: The Secret Source, exposes a paradox at the heart of hiring. While 77% of HR and recruiting professionals say active sourcing is “essential” or “very important” to their talent acquisition (TA) strategy, the majority of companies actively source fewer than half their hires.

The study, based on a survey of 1,000 US hiring and recruiting leaders over the last 12 months, highlights the mounting pressures on talent teams, the shortcomings of current sourcing technology, and the looming readiness gap: only 37% say they feel well prepared for AI, automation, and advanced analytics shaping the future of sourcing.

Key findings 

  • The sourcing paradox: Although three-quarters say active sourcing is very important or essential to their TA strategy, only 27% actively source more than half their hires. 

  • Top challenges: 58% struggle to verify skills on resumes, 47% find it difficult to identify candidates aligned with the company culture, and 43% cite a lack of skilled candidates in the market.

  • Tech gaps: Nearly half (46%) say their current sourcing tools are ineffective; integration failures and outdated candidate data are the biggest frustrations.

  • Future-readiness: Only 37% of sourcing teams feel prepared for the rise of AI, automation, and advanced analytics in recruitment.

Sector insights  

  • Retail: The sharpest sourcing paradox. 78% say active sourcing is essential, yet only 7% actively source more than half their hires – the widest value-action gap of any sector. Retail teams also report the lowest satisfaction with sourcing tools (31% vs. 54% industry-wide).

  • Financial Services: Less likely than average to struggle with finding qualified candidates (44% vs. 54%), but face the most severe resume credibility gap: 66% say verifying candidate skills is their biggest hurdle – the highest of any sector apart from education.

  • IT: Only 17% of IT organizations actively source more than half their hires, despite 83% saying active sourcing is essential. Recruiters cite outdated candidate data (44%) and integration gaps between tools (48%) as their biggest frustrations – pain points that persist even in a tech-first sector. Still, 67% plan to invest in new sourcing technology in the next 12 months. Looking ahead, IT professionals expect disruption less from skills shortages (27%) and more from AI and automation (54%) and advanced data & analytics (49%) – though many admit they are not fully prepared for these shifts.

  • Marketing & Advertising: Stand out for cultural fit challenges – 56% cite it as their top sourcing issue, more than any other industry. Marketing teams are also the most likely to invest in new sourcing technology (75% vs. 61% industry average), despite being the sector most likely to anticipate disruption from economic volatility and budget constraints (40% vs. 28%).

The best insights on HR and recruitment, delivered to your inbox.

Biweekly updates. No spam. Unsubscribe any time.

To learn more, read the report

Wouter Durville, our CEO and Co-Founder, says: 

“Sourcing teams are under more pressure than ever. They’re expected to deliver quality hires in a market where AI is rapidly reshaping talent acquisition, skills are harder to verify, and outdated tools can’t keep up. Our research shows that while nearly eight in ten leaders say active sourcing is vital, most still rely on passive hires because of these barriers.

Better sourcing comes down to three things: smarter signals on skills and culture, tools that integrate seamlessly, and clear ROI measurement so you can double down on what works and fix what doesn’t.”

Sourcing teams, this is your data-driven guide for sourcing success. The complete report is available here.

Notes to editors

  • About TestGorilla: TestGorilla is a global talent discovery platform that helps employers source and hire top talent based on proven skills. With access to 2m+ skills-tested candidates, a library of 350+ science-backed assessments, and bias-tested AI evaluation tools, it gives organizations a fairer, more predictive way to hire.

  • Methodology: Survey of 1,000 US professionals involved in sourcing between August 2024 and August 2025 (TA professionals, external recruiters, hiring managers, HR leaders, and business owners). Respondents were balanced across gender, age, and income brackets. Data collected via independent third-party survey panels.

  • Media contact: For additional data, visuals, or spokesperson quotes, contact Rebecca Parvin-Graham | PR & Communications Manager | press@testgorilla.com

Related posts

Blog thumbnail data and skills hiring

How data and skills are replacing traditional headhunting

what is talent sourcing featured image

What is talent sourcing?

how to assess design thinking skills featured image

The secret to hiring creatives: Evaluating design skills that matter

You've scrolled this far

Why not try TestGorilla for free, and see what happens when you put skills first.

Free resources

Skills-based hiring handbook cover image
Ebook
The skills-based hiring handbook
Ebook
How to elevate employee onboarding
Top talent assessment platforms comparison guide - carousel image
Ebook
Top talent assessment platforms: A detailed guide
The blueprint for boosting your recruitment ROI cover image
Ebook
The blueprint for boosting your recruitment ROI
Skills-based hiring checklist cover image
Checklist
The skills-based hiring checklist
Onboarding email templates cover image
Checklist
Essential onboarding email templates
HR cheat sheet cover image
Checklist
The HR cheat sheet
Employee onboarding checklist cover
Checklist
Employee onboarding checklist
Key hiring metrics cheat sheet cover image
Checklist
Key hiring metrics cheat sheet